Showing posts with label Senate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Senate. Show all posts

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Turnover in Senate Increasing, But Don't Expect Sweeping Changes

Last month, both FiveThirtyEight and CNN Politics did in-depth pieces on a curious phenomenon in the United States Senate.  As the graphic shows below, recently there have been an unusually high amount of Senate retirements.  This session is the third consecutive legislative session to show this.  45 Senators are serving in their first 6 year term.

There are multiple possible explanations for why this is occurring   Some believe that this is simply a generational shift.  Every 20-30 years, historians have found, their is higher than average turnover.  We seem to be hitting one of those periods of high turnover.

Others contend that these senators are leaving because right now, being an ex-senator is far more lucrative than being a current senator.  Jim DeMint notably left the Senate to take a well-paying job as president of the Heritage Foundation.  This is indicative of a new trend where jobs taken following retirement from congress are far better paying than they used to be.  Retired legislators can make money lobbying in the private sector or influencing their former colleagues.  

There are also some who argue it is the increased partisan nature of the Senate that has driven many to retire.  When Maine Senator Olympia Snowe retired, she cited the political climate as a principle reason she was leaving.  

This is also the main reason that despite the turnover in the Senate, the division in congress is likely to continue.  Do not expect sweeping reforms to come out of the Senate, for the people being elected are partisan standard waivers replacing far more moderate retirees.  At the ballot box, moderates are also being replaced by party hardliners.  Elizabeth Warren, a noted liberal, defeated moderate Republican Scott Brown, just one example of how polarized the Senate and the rest of congress is becoming.  Moderates are a dying breed in seems, and we are experiencing an extraordinary amount of partisan division.

Don't keep your fingers crossed that the new senators will want to compromise and work on political reform   They have their own agendas, and soon they will be up for reelection, meaning they will need to bend to their constituents in order to assure that they can remain in office.  

Saturday, November 17, 2012

Badly Needed Senate Procedure Reforms: Part 2

In the second part of our Senate reform series, we'll discuss secret holds.  In the last post, we discussed the filibuster, used as a means to delay or kill legislation   While the filibuster has been commonly used, especially recently, it is not the only way a senator can stall or stop a bill.

The Senate, it turns out, typically conducts business in the form of unanimous consent, which means that a single member can cause considerable consternation when other senators are trying to pass a measure.  This hold can be done without releasing one's name, hence the term "secret hold".  After some recent changes to the procedure, a senator can hold under anonymity for up to two days.  The problem: senators can still team up.  One will hold fro two days, then another.  The result is a killed bill.




Our proposal:

We need to adapt the rules to hold senators accountable.  Holds can still exist, but all holds should be public.  Senators should then explain to the American people why they have place a hold.  There is then a public record of why the senator is opposed.  Changing these rules should streamline the legislative process and make the system more open and transparent.

QK7UZB788X2Q